AIIP welcomes new Government guidance on PFI Reset

New NISTA guidance recognises the importance of public-private collaboration, with AIIP members helping to shape the approach to improving existing infrastructure partnerships.

The Association of Infrastructure Investors in Public Private Partnerships (AIIP) has welcomed the publication of new guidance from the National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (NISTA), setting out a framework for improving the performance of existing PFI projects.

Published on 16 November, the new PFI Reset guidance is an important step towards ensuring that long-term infrastructure partnerships continue to deliver high-quality public services, value for money for taxpayers and well-maintained public assets.

AIIP has been closely involved in the development of the guidance, working with NISTA and drawing on the practical experience of our members, supported by our founding adviser, Curshaw.

In particular, we welcome the inclusion of a dedicated section: “The private sector perspective”, which we wrote to reflect the experience and priorities of its investor members. The guidance explicitly recognises the importance of public authorities understanding the private sector's position when considering how to reset existing partnerships.

Curshaw have compiled a detailed analysis of where the new guidance addresses recommendations from our members and how this has been implemented in the new approach: PFI Reset: NISTA has set the framework — Curshaw

A more collaborative approach to PFI

The new guidance represents an important recognition that the best outcomes from public-private partnerships depend on collaboration, transparency and a shared commitment to delivering high-quality services.

Many existing PFI projects are performing successfully, but others face challenges relating to asset condition, service delivery, contract management or relationships between public and private partners. Often those issues can be exploited by unscrupulous consultants.

Rather than adopting a one-size-fits-all approach, NISTA's framework recognises that each project requires a proportionate response, informed by evidence and the particular circumstances of the contract. NISTA has moved to develop a Conflict Advisory Forum to address these issues earlier to avoid legal disputes.

Crucially, the guidance also emphasises that resetting a PFI project should be a joint endeavour, with public authorities, investors and service providers working together to identify problems and agree practical solutions.

This reflects an approach AIIP has consistently advocated: that constructive engagement, rather than adversarial contract management, offers the most effective route to securing sustainable improvements.

Clear leadership and responsibility

The guidance is clear on the importance of strong leadership (public and private), effective governance and open communication between all parties.

This includes clear responsibilities for contracting authorities, PFI company directors and service providers, alongside effective escalation arrangements to resolve problems before they develop into costly disputes.

The contribution also emphasises the importance of continuous improvement, with both public and private sector partners willing to review their approaches to contract management, asset maintenance and service delivery.

These principles are central to successful long-term partnerships and to protecting the interests of public service users, taxpayers and investors alike.

AIIP is grateful to NISTA for engaging constructively with the industry throughout the development of the guidance and to Curshaw for its specialist expertise and support in shaping AIIP's contribution.

Turning guidance into practical improvements

The guidance introduces a structured process for reviewing projects and identifying where change may be required.

A new Project Stocktake provides a starting point for examining performance, governance, relationships and asset condition. Where significant issues are identified, NISTA's Reset Routemap offers a framework for agreeing objectives, implementing improvements and ensuring that positive changes are sustained.

This is particularly important as increasing numbers of PFI contracts approach expiry, bringing greater focus to asset condition, maintenance obligations and the arrangements for handing back essential public infrastructure.

There remain practical questions about how reset arrangements will operate in individual projects, including the treatment of payment mechanisms, access to information and the resources needed to implement change. AIIP looks forward to continuing its engagement with NISTA and public sector partners on these issues.

The publication of the guidance is an important milestone, but successful implementation will ultimately depend on how effectively public and private sector partners work together.

AIIP and its members stand ready to play their part in turning the new guidance into practical improvements, ensuring that existing infrastructure partnerships continue to deliver for the communities and public services that depend on them.

Further reading:

Next
Next

Think tank warns NHS capital cuts risk undermining productivity